Russia’s Shadow Fleet – Understanding its Size, Activity and Relationships
The ceilings will be reassessed in mid-March with further reviews every two months. A transition period for refined products is currently in place for of 55 days, this excludes from the price cap vessels currently carrying Russian petroleum products that were purchased and loaded before Feb. 5, 2023 and unloaded before April 1, 2023. In this context, Russia has repeatedly stated that it will not work with the price cap, but the vast majority of seaborne Russian oil shipments rely on services provided by companies based in the G7.
Large volumes of Russian oil are shipped on Greek owned vessels and very significant numbers of Russian vessels are insured through the United Kingdom-based International Group of P&I Clubs. If Russia insists on not conforming to the price cap, it cannot use services located in G7 countries due to sanctions controls. Therefore, Russia needs to transport its oil output in order to maintain current cargo levels by other means, as the current Russian fleet alone does not have the capacity to do so. This scenario gives rise to the need for a substantial shadow or ghost fleet of vessels able to transport Russian oil at close to capacity as possible while potentially evading G7 sanctions and the crude and refined oil price caps.
There are multiple estimates as to how many vessels make up the Russian shadow fleet, ranging from 100 to a higher estimate of 6001 . While an exact number in the shadow fleet would be difficult to determine, there are certain vessels with particular characteristics and patterns that can be used in an assessment of ships likely to be involved in the transfer or movement of Russian oil. This paper seeks to identify and analyze the key tactics and methods employed by Russian and non-Russian vessels when attempting to evade sanctions on the movement of oil and its refined products.
− This paper estimates 443 tanker vessels (with a DWT greater than 10,000) are currently operating within the Russian shadow or ghost fleet
− The number of vessels with a wider potential for risk in regard to Russian sanctions is estimated to be 1,900. These are vessels of all nationalities and ownership that have made Russian port calls, STS transfers etc.
− From these 1,900 ships the majority are Greek owned and cover a wide range of flag registries from the Marshall Islands, Liberia and Panama
− New vessels have begun to work the Russian tanker routes. 35 new vessels have visited Russian oil ports for the first time in the period between Dec. 5, 2022 and Feb. 16, 2023
− Ceuta on the North African Mediterranean coast is the current hotspot for Russian oil STS (ship-to-ship) transfers, with a monthly average of 18 between October 2022 and January 2023
− Other STS transfer hubs for Russian oil are the Peloponnese region of Greece and South Korea
– Russian diesel appears to be finding a new home in North Africa with multiple cargo deliveries to Tunisia in 2023. For the first two months of 2023, Russian refined product cargoes delivered to Tunisia have already exceeded volumes in 2022
− An increasing number of vessels that once worked the Venezuelan oil cargo route and engaged in suspicious activity when delivering these shipments are moving over to Russian tanker routes
Shadow Fleet Estimation
Providing an estimation on the overall number of vessels in the shadow or ghost fleet is difficult to determine. One of the key reasons for the differences in numbers from various shipping brokers, traders and others is due to methodology. Certain methodologies account for port calls since the first oil cap on Dec. 5, 2022, while others might discount this due to it being an open and easily identifiable aspect of shipping Russian oil. Other estimations might not utilize ownership data due to a lack of authoritative sources.
The methodology used in this paper accounts for the following attributes:
− Vessels with a current Russian registration or ownership entity since the G7 oil price cap was introduced on Dec. 5, 2022
− Vessels making their first port call or STS with Russia after Dec. 5
− Vessels previously working Iranian or Venezuelan oil tanker routes but have now switched to Russian cargoes
− Vessels sold with missing ownership entities or having an unknown or undisclosed buyer since August 2022 (the G7 oil price cap was announced in September 2022)
From this list a number of ships have been identified as lifting Russian oil cargo within price cap limits due to trade patterns, flag, country registration and ownership investigation and were removed from the overall analysis. Also removed from the list are vessels with a tonnage below 10,000 DWT. Using this analysis, a total of 443 vessels are believed to be Russian ghost ships as of Feb. 27, 2023. The breakdown by ship type group is 316 crude oil vessels and 127 refined product tankers.
The 443 vessels within the ghost or shadow fleet suggests there is enough capacity for Russia to continue supplying its partners and markets. Recent estimates outlined the need for 240 ships to be available to Russia in order to maintain current seaborne crude exports.
Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence