Tanker Shipping – Profitability Still A Way Off For Loss-Making Tankers As Pandemic Drags On
New virus mutations and outbreaks have slowed the recovery in global oil demand as some countries lock down again and international travel remains complicated.
Drivers of demand and freight rates
To say that the summer has not been kind to the crude oil shipping industry would be an understatement. Average earnings have dropped below USD 10,000 per day since June for all crude oil tankers, with many trades offering negative earnings; freight rates are not high enough to cover voyage expenses, let alone operating and financing costs. Daily average VLCC earnings on 3 September stood at USD 8,138. According to BIMCO estimates, a standard VLCC must earn around USD 25,000 per day to break even. The last time average VLCC earnings were above this level was at the end of December 2020. Earnings for Suezmax and Aframax tankers stood at USD 9,194 and USD 8,367 per day, respectively, on 3 September.
A clear indication of the currently low activity in the VLCC market is the lack of volatility in earnings. The difference between the highest and lowest average earnings in August was just USD 1,183.
Oil product tankers have registered more movement in earnings. LR2 earnings reached USD 19,102 per day on 3 September, while LR1 earnings reached USD 13,521 per day.
In terms of demand for seaborne transportation of oil products, volumes have risen by 22.4% in the first six months of this year compared to 2020, but at 508.2m tonnes, volumes are, however, 13.4% lower than in the first half of 2019. Out of the major oil products, the largest increase in volumes compared with last year and smallest decrease compared to 2019 has been registered for gasoline, which is down 6.4% after the first six months of 2021 compared with pre-pandemic levels. In the same period, gasoline volumes have risen 35.9% compared with the first half of 2020 (source: Tradeviews).
Considering the sluggish recovery in international flight activity, it probably comes as no surprise that jet fuel has fallen the most compared with its pre-pandemic levels. In fact, demand for jet fuel has continued to fall this year compared to last. Volumes are down by 3.4% compared to the first half of 2020, and by 38.0% from the same period in 2019. In the first half of this year jet fuel accounted for 5.6% of total oil product volumes carried by sea, down from 7.9% in H1 2019, when they accounted for a larger share of activity.
In the US, the driving season is coming to an end and the supply of gasoline, a good proxy for demand, has returned to its 2015-2019 range over the summer. In the week ending 27 August, the supply of gasoline amounted to 9.6m barrels per day (bpd), down slightly from early July, when supply peaked at 10.0m bpd. Compared to 2019, the average amount of gasoline supplied per day between June and August is down 2.8%, despite a 9.2% increase from the summer of 2020.
A recovery in US domestic flight travel has also led to a recovery in jet fuel demand. However, with an average of 1.9m passengers a day, a recovery in international travel is needed to bring numbers back up to the 2.5m passengers per day recorded in the summer of 2019. In the week ending 27 August, the supply of jet fuel jumped up to 1.8m bpd, its highest level since January 2020.
In contrast to the year-on-year growth in demand for oil products in the US and much of the world, worldwide crude oil imports have fallen. Globally, exports of crude oil have totalled 849.8m tonnes, down 63.2m tonnes from H1 2020 and 121.7m tonnes lower than H1 2019 (source: Tradeviews), explaining the significant drops in freight rates.
To take an example, US seaborne crude oil exports have fallen 7.4% to 66.5m tonnes in the first half of 2021 compared with 71.8m tonnes in H1 2020, reversing years of strong growth in US crude oil exports since the export ban was lifted at the end of 2015. Measured in tonne miles, demand for shipping from US crude oil exports has dropped 5.7%.
Saudi Arabian crude oil exports are down 16.1% compared with last year. After record-high exports in H1 2020 of 177.3m tonnes, exports have fallen to 148.8m tonnes, just under 18% of total global seaborne crude oil exports.
In the Far East, the three largest importers of crude oil (China, South Korea and Japan) have seen volumes fall 6.2% in the first seven months of the year compared with the same period in 2020, exceeding the drop compared with pre-pandemic H1 in 2019. Compared with this period, the drop amounted to 2.7%, which was attributable to the high volumes of crude oil that were imported during the oil price war. Combined, the three countries have imported 442.8m tonnes of crude oil so far this year, which is equivalent to 2,214 VLCC loads (200,000 tonnes).
Despite the fact that more ships entering the fleet is hardly what the market currently needs, as the existing fleet already struggles to cover its costs and run with profit, the tanker fleet will inevitably grow this year. BIMCO expects the crude oil tanker fleet to grow by 2.7% this year, with a net addition of 12.8m DWT, and the oil product tanker fleet to grow by 3m DWT or 1.7%. This would be the lowest fleet growth recorded for product tankers since the early 2000s. BIMCO expects the growth rate to fall even further to 1.2% in 2022, as deliveries are expected to fall to about half of this year’s level. In a year of declining demand, keeping fleet growth as low as possible is essential.
The lower fleet growth for oil product tankers has not come from a fall in deliveries, which are in fact up this year at 7m DWT compared with 4.9m in 2020, but rather from a rise in demolition activity. BIMCO expects a record 4m DWT to be demolished this year, exceeding the previous record of 3.8m DWT from 2010. So far this year, 2.5m DWT have been demolished.
Product tanker demolitions include 612,760 DWT of LR2 tankers (six units) with an average age of around 20 years. Most of the demolished ships are MR/Handy size tankers, of which 37 have been demolished, totalling 1.6m DWT.
Despite crude oil tankers faring even worse in terms of earnings than their oil product counterparts, crude oil tankers have largely avoided demolition. So far this year, only 3.2m DWT of actively trading crude oil tankers have been demolished, exceeding the figure for product tankers. However, given that the crude oil tanker fleet is more than 2.5 times larger than the oil product fleet, these demolitions represent a much smaller part of the fleet being removed. BIMCO expects 5m DWT of crude oil tankers to be demolished in 2021, an increase from 2.7m DWT last year, but still much lower than current freight rates could suggest.
On the ordering front, new contracts for oil product tankers have totalled 4.1m DWT this year with a further 14.5m DWT of crude oil tankers being ordered.
As tanker owners hold on to their ships, hoping for better times ahead and not nearing bankruptcy as last year’s significant earnings cushion their bottom lines, the pandemic keeps extending the timeline for recovery. New virus variants and outbreaks in regions of the world with low vaccination rates continue to delay a recovery in the demand for oil. This is especially problematic as real volume growth in demand for tanker shipping over the past decade has primarily been driven by the countries that currently have low vaccination rates and which are now facing new outbreaks as a result.
At the latest OPEC+ meeting, held on 1 September, partners agreed to continue the current trajectory of adding 400,000 bpd every month. Ahead of this meeting, the alliance released its latest estimates, forecasting that oil demand will grow by 5.95m bpd this year compared to last, still 3m bpd short of 2019 levels. Looking forward, OPEC has adjusted its forecast for growth in 2022 to an increase of 4.2m bpd (+0.9m bpd from July forecast).
Just as global demand for oil is currently below its pre-pandemic levels, demand for shipping is on the decline because the stocks that were built up over the summer last year are now being used. In fact, US crude oil stocks are currently at their lowest level since January 2015, at 1,053 million barrels, down from their peak in June 2020, when they reached 1,195 million barrels. Lower stocks and rising demand indicate that either the US will have to start producing more crude oil or look to increase imports, a scenario that would be beneficial for the shipping industry. The US has been a leading voice in calls for OPEC to increase production as crude oil prices have risen.
As the northern winter approaches, which is traditionally tanker shipping’s strong season, demand will remain subdued, with little hope of tankers achieving profitable freight rates on open trades this year, unless seasonal issues can stimulate underlying demand to boost earnings. As demand is forecast to exceed 2019 levels in 2022, the outlook for tanker shipping is better next year. That said, better and good are not always the same thing and profitable rates may not be a reality until the second half of 2022.