The impact of Coronavirus – UK Club provides Members with FAQs
The Coronavirus pandemic has understandably generated a significant number of enquiries and questions from Members in recent weeks. In response to these enquiries, the UK P&I Club has sought to inform Members of the guidelines it will be working to and to answer some of the more common questions received regarding the impact of COVID-19 and the operation of Club cover. These FAQs have been placed on the Club’s website.
The UK Club has provided guidance to a number of Member enquiries, such as the following:
· Where a crewmember falls ill or dies due to COVID-19, is this covered under the ship’s P&I entry?
· What costs are covered under the Club’s quarantine rule?
· Will the Club reimburse crew medical costs and sick wages in circumstances where coronavirus is suspected to have been contracted during a crewmember’s employment on board an entered ship but was not detected until their return home due to the incubation period?
· In the event it is necessary for an entered ship to divert to arrange medical treatment ashore for a crewmember who has contracted COVID-19, what costs are covered by P&I?
Andrew Taylor, CEO, UK P&I Club, says: “In this unprecedented and extremely challenging time, we are committed to providing guidance to our Members on the impact of COVID-19 and the operation of Club cover. We have therefore collated the most common questions raised by our Members over recent weeks. The answers to these key questions highlight potential issues which may arise and provide reassurance to Members during this ongoing crisis.”
FAQ: Covid-19 and Club cover
The Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic has generated a significant number of enquiries and questions from Members in recent weeks. We have prepared the following FAQs to help guide Members on the most common questions asked regarding the impact of COVID-19 and the operation of Club cover.
For the latest updates on Covid-19, visit our dedicated resource page.
Q1. Where a crewmember falls ill or dies due to COVID-19, is this covered under the ship’s P&I entry?
P&I cover responds to a Member’s liability to pay damages or compensation for illness and death resulting from illness of any seaman including hospital, medical, funeral or other expenses necessarily incurred in relation to such illness or such death. Such liability will typically fall under the terms of an approved contract of employment or possibly under common law. If a serving crewmember falls ill or dies due to coronavirus, this would be treated in the same way as any other crew illness or death claim.
Q2. Will the Club reimburse crew medical costs and sick wages in circumstances where coronavirus is suspected to have been contracted during a crewmember’s employment on board an entered ship but was not detected until their return home due to the incubation period?
Members may have strict contractual obligations to crew which apply during service on board as well as travelling directly to and from the ship, during which crew may be exposed to COVID-19. The medical advice and governmental travel guidance will be relevant but the Club is generally sympathetic to reimbursement of a recently signed off crewmembers’ medical costs and sick wages for confirmed cases of COVID-19. Once repatriated, crewmembers should follow generally accepted WHO guidance on self-isolation or their national guidance in force at the time.
Q3. In cases of crew repatriation where the disembarking crew are required to stay at a hotel or other facility for a certain period for self-isolation as per the restriction of the country where the crew disembarks, will the Club reimburse the associated expenses incurred by the Member?
If none of the discharging crew are sick or exhibiting any symptoms and the requirement for quarantine of the crew either in a hotel or in a special facility is purely precautionary, the associated costs of keeping the crew in ‘quarantine’ – i.e. accommodation, travel and subsistence costs, crew wages, etc. would be considered as operational costs and not covered by P&I.
However, where a crewmember who is effectively in quarantine awaiting repatriation is taken ill or is injured or dies awaiting repatriation, it is likely that the crew contract and/or Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) will dictate that the Member is liable for the claim. In such circumstances, P&I cover will respond to that claim.
Q4. If otherwise healthy crew are required to be quarantined when disembarking from an entered ship where an actual or suspected case of COVID-19 has been detected, will the quarantine expenses (including accommodation, subsistence costs and crew wages paid during quarantine period) be covered?
In the absence of an outbreak of an infectious disease on board the entered ship, cover under the quarantine rule is not triggered. Consequently, the additional expenses incurred due to crewmembers being placed into quarantine on a precautionary basis are not be recoverable.
However, in circumstances where healthy crew are required to be quarantined having disembarked from an infected ship, cover in respect of quarantine expenses under Rule 2 Section 16 would be available.
Q5. In the event it is necessary for an entered ship to divert to arrange medical treatment ashore for a crewmember who has contracted COVID-19, what costs are covered by P&I?
Regardless of the nature of the illness, it may be necessary for a ship to deviate from its intended voyage in order to obtain appropriate medical care for a sick crewmember on board. The net costs of the diversion in respect of fuel, insurance, wages, stores, provisions and port charges are covered under Rule 2 Section 7 to the extent that such costs exceed what would have been incurred regardless of the diversion.
Given the rapidly changing situation around the world, Members should contact the Managers in the first instance to obtain up to date information regarding possible restrictions at the intended port of disembarkation as port restrictions could affect the ability to disembark the crewmember and alternative arrangements may need to be made.
Q6. What costs are covered under the Club’s quarantine rule?
Under Rule 2 Section 16, the Club will indemnify the owner of an entered ship for the additional expenses incurred as a direct consequence of an outbreak of infectious disease on that ship, including quarantine and disinfection expenses and the net loss to the owner (over and above such expenses as would have been incurred but for the outbreak) in respect of the cost of fuel, insurance, wages, stores, provisions and port charges. Note that there has to be an outbreak on the ship in question in order for cover to apply.
If a ship is delayed off a port because of a suspicion of infection, or as a result of a routine restriction on ships arriving from certain ports, then cover is not triggered.
The Club will also reimburse quarantine and disinfection expenses when a vessel is required to comply with a quarantine order given by local or national authorities – but again, only if there is an outbreak of disease on the ship in question.
Q7. The contracts for a number of the ship’s crew have expired or are due to expire soon and owners are not able to effect the necessary crew changes in accordance with the terms of the crew contract due to the outbreak of coronavirus and the restrictions in place in various ports. Will this affect the ship’s seaworthiness?
No, provided safe manning levels for the ship are maintained in accordance with flag state requirements.
Q8. Is P&I cover prejudiced where there is an overlap of crewmembers on board the ship as those signing off are unable to be repatriated at the end of their contracts due to various travel restrictions imposed in order to combat the spread of COVID-19?
P&I cover will continue to respond to the Member’s legal liabilities towards crewmembers remaining on board with expired contracts in the usual manner until such time as they are off the ship and have been repatriated.
Q9. If a superintendent or other office based personnel visit an entered vessel and subsequently contract the coronavirus infection, is this covered?
The Club covers Members’ legal liabilities to third parties only arising from or in connection with the operation of an entered ship. Superintendents or other office based personnel are not employed by the ship and would be considered as supernumeraries on board. Liability would only arise is if the ship was negligent in some way in causing their illness. If the ship was negligent in causing their illness, then Club cover would respond to that claim. However, provided all sensible precautions are taken it is unlikely the ship would be found responsible and any liabilities would therefore arise under their contracts of employment and would be covered by the employer/shoreside insurer of the personnel involved.
Q10. In the event a port is closed or temporarily closed due to a quarantine order, would the ship be liable for cargo claims arising from this delay?
Cargo related losses due to quarantine are unlikely. However, an owner could face a claim related to (i) delay in delivery or loading, (ii) loss of or reduction in value of cargo as a result of a quarantine order by competent authorities, or (iii) inability to deliver to a named port because of a vessel’s quarantine or closure of a port.
Generally, under bill of lading terms and international bill of lading conventions such as the Hague Visby rules, the owner has full defences to delay claims. An outbreak of an infectious disease leading to quarantine would generally be a force majeure event. It is an event beyond the owner’s control and therefore the owner should not be liable, but in the event of a ‘rogue’ decision, cover will respond.
Depending on the type of cargo and type of disease, cargo may be destroyed or may reduce in value. As with delay, an owner should have full defences to this type of claim. However, if the owner is found legally liable, P&I cover will respond.
Q11. Are claims for loss of a commercial fixture or other consequential losses in the event of a port closure due to a quarantine order covered by P&I?
Claims for loss of time or loss of hire fall outside the scope of Club cover. If a vessel is detained due to a quarantine order and misses a laycan date for its next fixture, P&I will not indemnify an owner for loss of profit or other commercial losses.
Source: UK P&I Club